Note: I originally wrote this for another blog. However, it is important part of my story.
Dysgraphia is related to dyslexia. Dysgraphia affects fine motor skills and ability to write legibly. Like dyslexia it is often misunderstood. Many times a child with dyslexia may do very well in school except for writing legibly therefore it is assumed that he/she writes too quickly, is lazy, careless or does not care. To further complicate the matter dysgraphia is more than just messy or illegible handwriting.
So what is dysgraphia? According to the National Institute for Neurological Disorders and Stroke: “Dysgraphia is a neurological disorder characterized by writing disabilities.” (1)
The most notable characteristic of dysgraphia is illegible or poor handwriting. Inconsistency with handwriting is a part of dysgraphia. Writing may contain a mixture of print and script, upper and lower case letters, varying sizes, shapes and slant of letters. Inconsistent spacing of words, letters and margins are also common. Punctuation, spelling and syntax errors are common traits of dysgraphia. Holding the pen incorrectly such as too close to the page or holding thumb over two fingers and writing from the wrist are also signs of dysgraphia. For someone with dysgraphia the process of writing letters is a consuming task that leads to omitted letters or words. The speed of writing is also very slow. (2) There is a large gap between written communication and ideas expressed orally. (3)
Unlike dyslexia, dysgraphia directly affect the ability for written expression. Dyslexia is a language disorder while dysgraphia affects motor skills. Dysgraphia affects the process of written expression. Many children with dysgraphia are able to create and wonderful stories but the process of physically writing is so difficult and painful that written expression is hindered. Like dyslexia, dysgraphia affects all areas of the child’s academic career. Slow or illegible handwriting can make completing even the simplest assignment a daunting task.
The stress and emotional issues that dysgraphia can cause for children should also be considered. (4) Children with dysgraphia are often very bright and have good verbal skills. It is very frustrating to have ideas or thoughts trapped inside one’s head and being unable to express them fluently. Being asked to re-copy work and not be able to produce quality work causes frustration. It is very disconcerting for a child to put forth his or her best effort and have it rejected and be labeled slow or lazy.
I am severely dysgraphic and for most of my life viewed myself as very poor writer. Handwriting lessons in school were pure torture. Most of my teachers from 4th grade through sixth grades believed that perfect penmanship was more important than the content. Handwriting papers with more than 3-5 errors were required to be redone. My 6th grade teacher may have done more to inhibit my abilities as a writer than any other teacher. She had a rule that any paper with more than 3 cross-outs or errors was not acceptable and would often be ripped up in front of the class and trashed. She seemed to delight in destroying my papers in front of the class. Her rationale for this was that if I had to redo enough papers I would learn to be neat. According to this teacher I would never be successful unless I learned to write neatly. What I learned was that I hated writing and would do as little of it as possible. For me a computer is the great equalizer. My keyboarding and computer skills are well above average. I am able to create wonderful looking documents with little stress. Using a computer allows me to focus on the content of what I am saying without worrying about legibility or spelling.
1. National Institute for Neurological Disorders and Stroke. “NINDS Dysgraphia Information Page” [http://www.ninds.nih.gov/disorders/dysgraphia/dysgraphia.htm].
2. Ed Keller, webmaster. “Dysgraphia” [http://www.as.wvu.edu/~scidis/dysgraphia.html]
3. National Center for Learning Disabilities. “Dysgraphia” [http://www.ncld.org/index.php?option=content&task=view&id=468]
4. International Dyslexia Association. “Just the Facts … Dysgraphia” [http://www.interdys.org/fact%20sheets/Dysgraphia%20FS%20N.pdf]
13 thoughts on “Dysgraphia Explained”
I am enjoying reading your blog, lots of good information. I can see in reading I have done and from experience with kids in our family that there is an overlap between the gifted, autistic/adhd and the dyslexic/dysgraphic groups. I find it discouraging that so many schools/teachers are focused on the behavior management of these kids, rather than focusing on the best teaching practices and early intervention. But I am hopeful that change is in the air.
The link between autism & ADHd is a recent discovery.
Dyslexic & dysgraphia are related disorders.
What I mean is, since many kids with ADHD or spectrum disorders are found to have dyslexia and or dysgraphia, that it would benefit the kids if schools paid attention to “behavior as communication of learning difficulties” rather than assume a child only has ADHDor spectrum disorder that must be addressed through behavior management. Paying attention to the specific educational needs of these kids should be first and foremost. Know what I mean?? I think what I am speaking of is definitely true of the high functioning kids that go unrecognized, but I also hear from friends of more severely autistic kids that they struggle to get those kids educational needs met.
Yes it is not uncommon for someone to have ADHD and dyslexia or dysgraphia. However, I’ve read some recent research that indicates ADHD may be related or connected to Autism spectrum disorders.
Dyslexia & Dysgraphia are learning disabilities. To be learning disabled someone must have an average or higher intelligence. It is possible for someone with the language side of dyslexia have a high enough IQ that they are able to compensate so that it doesn’t prevent academic performance from being in the normal range. That can’t make it hard for students with dyslexia to get help because they do not meet the criteria for services.
I’m working on a school project. I’m writing a book on mental disabilities from the view of people who actually have to live with them. I’m not taking a scientific approach, I want a personal approach. So would you allow me to use some of your blogs on ADHD and dysgraphia in the book, or could you write me one or two that is specifically about daily life trying to get others to understand how you think so they can help you.?
Will do with one clarification neither dysgraphia or ADHD are mental disabilities
I’m ADHD also. I believe them to be different operating software. That’s the angle I’m writing the book on, because I know it’s the case. We aren’t defective, we’re different.
Could you e-mail it to me at firstname.lastname@example.org ?
I’ve struggled with dysgraphia for my entire life. I’m now 59. I could write a book about my experiences with frustration and anger at a system that wouldn’t listen to me (in fact, I might write that book someday)- I could have told them that dysgraphia was a real thing decades before it was recognized. I have always said “Don’t try to fix me, because I’m not broken.”
Dysgraphia is even more difficult to grasp than dyslexia. Technology is the best solution for many of the issues. However that wasn’t available when either of us were in school
I use technology now, and it certainly does help. I made it through to a bachelor’s degree by brute force- I had to take many classes more than once. I was nearly 31 when I graduated. At 44, I went back for a Master’s and that’s when I found out that there was a diagnosis for what I’d always known was my peculiarity. Since then, I got a Ph.D. and am a university instructor now. These days, anyone who needs it gets accommodation and assistance. I have no problem with that- I just wish it had been there for me.
Because of my inability to make decent grades, my parents were very disappointed in me. I evaluated in the highest bracket of intelligence, but I could not make even moderately good grades. They took me to a clinic to have me evaluated for why I did so poorly in school, and were told that I was just lazy. I can do anything in the world, except hand write acceptably. Even after I was “diagnosed” many years later, my parents refused to accept it. They had such a long-standing vested interest in their image of me as simply lazy or stubborn that they couldn’t give it up.
I take exception to it being called a “learning disability.” I learned just fine; better than most. I call it a “conformity disability.” So, I ended up being a skeptic and a non-conformist in many other ways, as well.
By definition a learning disability means that something prevents someone with an average or higher from learning. It is not a matter of conforming to standards. It doesn’t mean you can’t learn but you learn differently.